Realty Times March 19, 2001

FTC Accuses Major Firms Of "Predatory" Lending
by Lew Sichelman

For the 15th time in the past three years, the Federal Trade Commission is alleging claims of "predatory" lending. This time, the accused firms are among the largest U.S. lenders.

According to the FTC, Associates First Capital Corporation and Associates Corporation of North America, known jointly as The Associates, engaged in "systematic and widespread abusive lending practices, commonly known as 'predatory lending.'"

In addition to The Associates, the complaint also names as defendants Citigroup Inc. and CitiFinancial Credit Company, Citigroup's consumer finance arm, as successors to The Associates.

The FTC alleges that The Associates violated the Truth in Lending Act, Fair Credit Reporting Act, and Equal Credit Opportunity Act. The federal agency claims that the companies used unfair collection tactics. The FTC also alleges the company violated the Federal Trade Commission Act by inducing unsuspecting and unsophisticated home owners to refinance existing debts into home loans with high interest rates, costs, and fees, and to purchase high-cost credit insurance.

The charges are a real kick in the pants for Citigroup, which spent $31 billion to acquire the Irving, Texas-based firm last November. In response to consumer complaints and to placate federal regulators, the big banking company said it would voluntarily adopt policies to help guard against abuses in its new "subprime" lending unit.

But consumer groups are taking great delight in the FTC complaint. They had objected strenuously to the merger unless regulators forced Citigroup to put more teeth into its plan to clean up The Associates.

According to the FTC, its investigation found that The Associates hid essential information from consumers, misrepresented loan terms, and packed optional fees to raise the loan costs.

"What had made the alleged practices more egregious is that they primarily victimized consumers who were the most vulnerable -- hard working homeowners who had to borrow to meet emergency needs and often had no other access to capital," the FTC's Jodie Bernstein said.

At the time the merger was completed, The Associates was one of the nation's largest "subprime" lenders. In 1999, according to public corporate records, the total dollar amount of all outstanding loans in The Associates' U.S. consumer finance portfolio was $29.7 billion. In that year, The Associates serviced 480,000 home equity loans.

Subprime lending, refers to the extension of loans to persons who are considered to be high-risk borrowers. The Associates, like other subprime lenders, charged its customers prices that were substantially higher than those available to borrowers with good credit in the prime market.

According to the FTC's complaint, the company obtained its customers through a variety of means, including direct mail offers that in some cases included "live checks," and the purchase of retail installment contracts.

Once in the Associates' loan portfolio, customers were aggressively solicited to take out new loans and refinance their existing debts into a single debt consolidation loan, typically a home equity loan.

The complaint alleges that promotional materials and sales pitches stressed -- in many cases, falsely -- that debt consolidation loans would lower customers' monthly payments and save them money.

The Associates trained its employees to tell consumers there would be "no out-of-pocket fees" or "no up front out-of-pocket costs" with its loans, the complaint charges, when in fact its mortgage loans came with high points and closing costs.

Consumers also were told, according to the FTC, that they would save money when consolidating existing debts into a home equity loan with the Associates.

Examples shown in the company's solicitations accurately illustrated the potential savings.

But, according to the complaint, the comparisons did not take into account the loan fees and closing costs typically added to the consumer's loan principal. Further, the comparisons did not reveal that with some loans, consumers would still owe the entire principal amount in a "balloon payment" at the end of the loan term.

The FTC complaint also charges the company engaged in practices designed to "induce borrowers to purchase, unknowingly, optional credit insurance products," a practice known as "packing."

According to the complaint, employees would quote prospective borrowers a monthly payment amount that would include a package of optional credit insurance products. These insurance products were intended to cover the borrower's loan payments in various circumstances, such as death, accident, illness or loss of employment, and the premiums were then added to the principal amount of the loan

Employees, says the FTC, referred to these products as "total payment protection," if they mentioned them at all, and were trained (until at least mid-1998) to quote the monthly payment with the cost of the insurance automatically included.

At the loan closings, according to the complaint, consumers were rushed through the process. If a borrower noticed that insurance products were being added to the loan, employees used various tactics to discourage them from removing the insurance, the complaint alleges.

The FTC also charged that The Associates employed abusive and unfair tactics in collecting on their loans, including:

  • Disclosing consumers debt information to third parties without the consumer's consent.

  • Calling consumers at their place of employment after being advised by the consumer that such calls were inconvenient or not permitted.

  • Making repeated and continuous telephone calls to consumers with intent to annoy, abuse or harass.

    The FTC has asked the court to prohibit the defendants from violating the FTC Act and other laws in the future in connection with offering and extending credit. It is also asking the court to "award redress to all borrowers who were injured as a result of the defendants' practices."

    For more articles by Lew Sichelman, please press here.



  • Copyright © 2001 Realty Times. All Rights Reserved.

    With an award winning staff of writers providing up to the minute real estate news and advice, thousands of REALTORS® in North America reporting daily market conditions, and a nationally broadcast television news program, Realty Times is the one-stop shop for real estate information. That's why over 10,000 real estate professionals have turned to us for their publicity needs.