Recent interests concerning Homestore.com (NASDAQ: HOMS) stock purchases by NAR officials
have resulted in the organization appointing an ad hoc committee to develop a
policy for dealing with potential conflicts of interest when REALTOR®
representatives serve on boards of directors of companies doing business with
the trade association.
The NAR decided to empanel the committee after NAR President Sharon Millett
and President-elect Dennis Cronk voluntarily disclosed their stock ownership
interests in Homestore.com, operator of the REALTOR.com Web site, which is partially owned by the NAR.
To erase any suggestion of conflict, Millett sold her shares so she could
continue to serve on boards working with Homestore. Rather than sell his
shares, Cronk said he would not serve on the board.
Both Millett and Cronk currently are out of the country on NAR business and
could not be reached for additional comment.
Earlier this month Millett and Cronk told the NAR Leadership team they had
been on Homestore’s "friends and family" list that had allowed them to
purchase shares of Homestore at the IPO price of about $20 per share.
In a pre-IPO lottery, all Realtor members were given a chance to purchase 100
shares at the IPO price. The shares were sold on condition that they not be
resold for at least six months.
By virtue of their executive status, Millett and Cronk were offered
additional shares without the sale date restriction.
The disclosure stated that, "At the time of the IPO, Dennis Cronk bought
16,500 shares at the IPO price of $20 per share. Also at the time of the IPO,
Sharon Millet bought 15,000 shares at the IPO price of $20 per share.
"She immediately found it difficult having limited participation in
discussions and votes at the Leadership Team meetings concerning
Homestore.com and technology issues because of the conflict her stock
ownership caused. Therefore, she subsequently sold all her stock within 10
business days of the IPO."
It is not known how much Millett received for her shares. During that
interval, the Homestore stock price was reaching the low $40s.
NAR leader Joe Hanauer also was provided 40,000 options, exercisable over the
next ten years at the IPO price of $20.
Some rank and file members of the NAR have lodged complaints against
Millett’s and Cronk and have called for an inquiry into their stock dealings.
They argue Millett and Cronk should not be allowed to profit beyond what rank and
file members have been allowed to profit.
What do you think?