Guest cottage, courtyard pool and custom treehouse add character and charm to renovated Sarasota property
SARASOTA, Fla. (March 18, 2026) — A restored 1920 Craftsman residence set on a rare double lot has entered the market in Sarasota’s coveted West of Trail neighborhood for $4.19 million. Located at 1611 Hyde Park Street, the property is represented by Lori Carey and Leslie Dufresne, global real estate advisors with Premier Sotheby’s International Realty’s Downtown Sarasota office. View the listing here.
Originally built in 1920 and comprehensively renovated in 2025 and 2026, the gated estate preserves its architectural character while introducing modern systems, finishes and impact windows and doors across 3,609 total square feet.
The main residence includes three bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths, anchored by a main-level primary suite with direct access to the private courtyard pool and spa. Large-format porcelain block flooring runs throughout the home, complemented by updated lighting and curated design details introduced during the renovation.
The kitchen is designed for both daily living and entertaining, centered around a large quartz island, new appliances and a natural gas five-burner range. A dining nook overlooks the courtyard, while adjacent living areas connect seamlessly to the home’s outdoor spaces.
Outdoor living is a defining feature of the estate. A heated saltwater pool and spa with rock fountain sit within a private courtyard, accompanied by an outdoor kitchen, multiple balconies, a sweeping front porch and mature Florida landscaping enhanced by architectural lighting.
Adding further charm to the grounds is a custom-built children’s treehouse fort and chicken coop, distinctive features that contribute to the property’s storybook character.
A detached, air-conditioned two-car garage includes a private guest cottage above, featuring one bedroom, an office and one bath. Additional covered parking provides flexibility for guests, extended family or potential rental use.
Located near Hillview Street’s dining and shopping district, Morton’s Market, Sarasota Bay and downtown Sarasota, the property offers a rare opportunity to own a restored historic home in one of the city’s most established neighborhoods.
QUOTE:
“West of Trail continues to attract buyers who value Sarasota’s architectural history but want the comfort of a fully updated home. Properties that combine historic character, a double lot and additional living spaces like a guest cottage are increasingly difficult to find.”
- Lori Carey and Leslie Dufresne, global real estate advisors, Premier Sotheby’s International Realty’s Downtown Sarasota office
About Premier Sotheby’s International Realty
Headquartered in Naples, Florida, Premier Sotheby’s International Realty has over 1,200 real estate professionals in 40 locations throughout Florida and North Carolina. Premier Sotheby’s International Realty also benefits from an association with the storied Sotheby's auction house, established in 1744. The brokerage was founded by The Lutgert Companies, a prominent member of Southwest Florida’s business community since 1964, and is proudly associated with Peerage Realty Partners. For more information, visit premiersothebysrealty.com.
