Are Real Estate Broker Commissions Under Attack?

Written by Posted On Saturday, 06 March 2021 06:38

Broker commissions for residential real estate are being challenged. With more and more home buyers relying more on technology for video-tours and neighborhood research, “traditional” real estate commissions are being challenged and yet have largely remained unchanged. Paid by the home seller, the commissions are typically as high as six percent, three percent being paid to the seller’s agent and three percent being paid to the buyer’s agent. Across Europe and Asia, real estate commissions generally range from one to two percent of the contract sale.

Legal Challenges

Over the past two years, seven different lawsuits have been filed, brought by private home sellers, an online brokerage, groups of California brokers, and the US Justice Department, claiming that brokers’ practices in charging and collecting commissions violate US Antitrust laws and amount to a conspiracy to keep their fees artificially inflated.

One such lawsuit has been brought by REX, an online brokerage whose fee start at two percent. When REX represents a home buyer and is given a three percent fee from the seller’s agent, it will give the buyer 50% of its broker commission back to the buyer as a rebate. In Oregon, REX filed suit in December 2020, challenging Oregon’s policy of banning REX and other brokers from refunding the commissions back to the buyer. REX is looking to potentially file suit in Louisiana, Missouri, and Tennessee which have similar anti-rebate laws.

Other suits have been filed against the National Association of Realtors, and in April 2019, the US Justice Department began investigating whether brokers steered their buyers to homes that offered larger commissions, thereby omitting brokers who may have been willing to collect less. In November 2020, the Justice Department filed and settled an antitrust case alleging the National Association of Realtors have “established and enforced illegal restraints on competition,” and asked the association to provide transparency around commissions to buyers and sellers.

Typically, brokers have the current commission fee structure to protect both buyers and sellers as each agent comes to the table representing their client’s best interests. Yet, during the pandemic, many home buyers started relying more on on-line resources to find their home purchase. As a result, there is the argument that since home buyers are doing more of the legwork in their home searches that broker commissions should be reduced.

Change is Brewing

As a result of the Justice Department settlement, Redfin, the online real estate brokerage announced that it will publish agent commissions on thousands of its public listings. This sense of transparency may change the traditional commission fee structure as more and more buyers and sellers may wish to negotiate broker commission rates.

This pandemic has created challenges for us all. It has also created disruptions in the real estate industry as residential purchasing and selling has had to resort to technology as traditional open houses and meeting face to face with buyers and sellers were not happening. With the distribution of  vaccines to acceleration, the question remains if our old ways of transacting real estate deals will revert back to pre-COVID-19 days.

While change is all around us, our law firm, Oppenheim Law, and our title company, Weston Title & Escrow, Inc. remains consistent.  For over 30+ years, we are here for you.  Should you need assistance in purchasing, or have a legal question about a potential purchase, our team at Oppenheim Law is here for you.  Our sister company, Weston Title & Escrow, Inc., is able to assist you with your closing.

Roy Oppenheim

From the Trenches

Rate this item
(0 votes)
Roy Oppenheim

From Wall Street to Main Street, Roy Oppenheim is a successful serial entrepreneur and attorney focusing on Florida real estate, foreclosure defense, loss mitigation and Internet ventures.

He founded Oppenheim Law in 1989 with his wife Ellen Pilelsky and uniquely positioned the Firm as one of Florida’s leading boutique law firms in Weston, Florida.

Serving national, international, and local clients, Mr. Oppenheim has the highest rating (A-V) conferred by Martindale Hubbell Law Directory, the most respected directory of lawyers and law firms in the U.S.

In 1989, Mr. Oppenheim also co-founded and served as general counsel to ShopSmart Corp., the company that originated and owned the GNC Gold Card Program, a program that continues to this day and was one of the first cross-promotional programs of its kind.

In addition, in 1994, he co-founded Weston Title & Escrow, the oldest title company in Weston, Florida, and he currently serves as its Vice President. In 1999, Mr. Oppenheim served a one-year term on the board of directors for Catalina Lighting, a publicly traded company on the New York Stock Exchange.

Growing up in the Bronx, Mr. Oppenheim learned to be focused on success and driven to always persevere for opportunity.

In 2009, he started the South Florida Law Blog, which was voted the best business and technology blog by the South Florida Sun-Sentinel. He also serves as an expert witness on title industry practices.

Mr. Oppenheim has also co-authored two law review articles, Deconstructing The Black Magic of Securitized Trusts, published in the Stetson University Law Review’s Spring 2012 Edition, and The Emperor’s New Clothes, published in the William & Mary Business Law Review Volume 6.

Today, Mr. Oppenheim is a sought-after legal expert on issues relating to the real estate crisis and beyond. In addition to his own blog, he also has been a contributor to Yahoo! Homes, and featured on HuffPost Live, FOX News, and Lifetime TV. In addition he has been quoted in prominent national publications, including USA Today, The New York Times and Huffington Post, among others. Mr. Oppenheim also understands the power of social media, and can be found on a variety of social media platforms.

Mr. Oppenheim also speaks fluent German.

Admissions

  • Florida Bar, 1987; Member of the Real Property Probate and Trust Law Section
  • New York Bar, 1987; United States District for the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York, 1987
  • U.S. District Court, Southern and Middle Districts of Florida, 1993

Education

  • Princeton University, A.B., cum laude, 1982
  • Northwestern University School of Law, J.D., 1986
    • Member of the Northwestern University Law Review
    • Member of the National Moot Court Team

Original source:  https://www.oppenheimlaw.com/who-we-are/meet-our-team/roy-d-oppenheim-esq/ 

https://www.oppenheimlaw.com

Search by State:

Agent Resource

How to capture your next prospect - click here

Realty Times

From buying and selling advice for consumers to money-making tips for Agents, our content, updated daily, has made Realty Times® a must-read, and see, for anyone involved in Real Estate.